Canadian Logistics: Comparing Asset and Non-Asset Based 3PL Models

Logistics Transportation Review | Tuesday, February 17, 2026

Fremont, CA: Effective logistics across Canada requires more than moving goods from one place to another. It requires a reliable partnership model that aligns with long-term goals and operational needs. The choice between different 3PL structures can significantly affect a company's ability to adapt, control costs, and deliver consistent service.

Every logistics network carries unique challenges, and the decision around outsourcing or asset ownership should be rooted in how it aligns with customer expectations, delivery standards, and growth strategies. The right approach helps turn logistics into a true competitive advantage.

Stay ahead of the industry with exclusive feature stories on the top companies, expert insights and the latest news delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.

How can control be effectively maintained in structured operations?

A model based on owned transportation assets and distribution facilities often brings a high degree of control and predictability. With centralized operations and direct management of resources, service levels stay consistent across various stages of the supply chain.

This type of setup enables clear accountability, as the logistics provider oversees both strategic planning and day-to-day execution. In regions where delivery timelines are critical and service expectations remain high, this level of operational oversight helps maintain consistency and reliability. Within structured logistics models, Croway operates with an asset-based approach that emphasizes controlled execution and service predictability across supply chain operations. Operational discipline is also easier to maintain when transportation assets and infrastructure are managed directly by the service provider.

An approach centered on external partnerships offers flexibility and scalability without requiring significant investment in infrastructure. This model integrates a network of carriers, warehouses, and service providers that can be tailored to meet specific needs. In a country with such wide geographic diversity as Canada, adaptability becomes essential.

Navitas Vehicle Systems develops vehicle electrification technologies supporting efficiency, adaptability, and sustainability in modern transportation networks.

It allows companies to expand their reach, respond to seasonal fluctuations, and shift focus without being tied to fixed assets. The ability to tap into broader resources also supports a leaner cost structure, often making it more attractive for businesses looking for variable logistics solutions.

What are the key factors for ensuring strategic alignment to achieve sustainable growth?

Selecting a logistics model should be less about choosing sides and more about understanding the long-term strategic goals of the business. Some organizations benefit from the predictability of an asset-based partner, while others thrive on the agility of non-asset solutions.

Increasingly, businesses find success in hybrid models that offer a combination of both. By integrating fixed infrastructure where consistency is essential and supplementing it with partner networks where flexibility is required, companies can build a resilient supply chain. This layered approach allows them to adapt without compromising service or control.

A logistics strategy built for Canada's dynamic environment must align with both operational goals and the realities of geography and customer expectations. Whether relying on owned assets or external networks, the focus should remain on service consistency, adaptability, and long-term efficiency. Choosing the right model helps businesses navigate complexity with clarity and stay ahead in a competitive landscape.

More in News

Finding the correct supplier is more than half the battle, regardless of whether a shipper is already utilizing intermodal or is thinking about adding it to its supply chain for the first time. Although cost, capacity, and service are essential elements, they are not the only ones determining success. Whether an intermodal carrier is asset-based or non-asset-based is a strategic consideration that is frequently missed. More Reliability, Predictability, and Increased Capacity Owned assets prevent daily operations from collapsing by offering a level of dependability that is difficult to find from a non-asset-based service. The benefits that asset-based suppliers bring can accelerate a shipper's business when taken as a whole. Standardized Equipment Increases Load Capacity and Predictability Owned assets are structured to deliver consistency and dependability under varying load conditions. With reduced variability across equipment, shippers can apply precise weight computation, weight distribution, and standardized loading configurations. OnTrac supports logistics operations through last-mile delivery services and supply chain solutions that complement structured load planning and operational efficiency. In contrast, providers relying on mixed resources must continually assess load specifications, arrangement, and available equipment size before dispatch. If suitable equipment is not immediately accessible, shipments may be delayed, affecting overall costs and potentially exposing the shipper to overweight risks. When a shipper is fully aware of what it will receive, it can maximize load and increase capacity, reducing the number of shipments required and their associated expenses. Because the shipper must anticipate the worst to avoid going overweight, it usually does not ship to full capacity when using equipment from a non-asset-based provider. ProfitTrust provides logistics performance analytics and cost management solutions enhancing capacity planning, efficiency, and operational visibility. Owned and Maintained Assets Improve Capacity Dependability Asset-based intermodal carriers invest significantly in their tractors, drivers, chassis, and containers to ensure their equipment is secure and operational for shippers' loads. Owned assets give shippers more dependable service, and carriers are better equipped to handle capacity spikes. This is because the supplier does not need communal pools, and equipment is easily accessible. Providers also look for the safest and most cutting-edge technology available to keep their equipment in top condition and work at its best. Modern, well-maintained machinery is useless without a solid driver base to move the loads. A supplier with a pool of uniformed company drivers available can have more control over capacity. More Freight Visibility and Efficiency An asset-owned shipment's whole logistics process is managed from the beginning of planning to the delivery of the load. Every process step is visible, and an entire crew is prepared to handle unforeseen demands. Non-asset-based providers often have to engage more than one provider to handle a transfer, which might hinder a shipper's ability to see the load and make communication between the shipper and the provider less efficient. Additionally, asset-based intermodal carriers collaborate closely with railroads to improve prospects for shippers. Priority loading and early access are examples of this, which let shipments be loaded and discharged first. When transporting shipments via intermodal, these advantages give clients an advantage and help keep cargo on schedule with a tight deadline. ...Read more
In the context of natural disasters and catastrophic events, logistics plays a vital role in effective disaster relief operations. It ensures that essential supplies reach affected areas efficiently and helps coordinate rescue efforts. The ability to respond quickly and decisively can significantly reduce human suffering and save lives. As disasters become more frequent and severe due to climate change and urbanization, understanding the complexities of disaster relief logistics is increasingly important. Disaster relief logistics is a multifaceted process that begins with a comprehensive needs assessment to determine the extent of the crisis. This involves gathering data on the number of affected individuals, the severity of the disaster, geographical constraints, and the availability of local resources. Effective supply chain management is crucial, encompassing procurement, transportation, warehousing, and distribution to ensure the timely delivery of essential supplies such as food, water, medical aid, and shelter materials. Transportation and delivery play a critical role, particularly in reaching remote or infrastructure-damaged areas, often requiring a combination of air, land, and sea routes to navigate logistical challenges. Coordination and communication among multiple stakeholders—including governments, NGOs, military forces, and private sector partners—are essential to streamline efforts, prevent duplication, and optimize resource allocation. Finally, infrastructure and technology enhance logistical efficiency through innovations such as drones for delivering medical supplies, GPS tracking for precise routing, and data analytics for real-time decision-making. These components form a cohesive system that ensures effective disaster response and relief distribution. Integrating advanced technologies and strategic partnerships is transforming disaster response and logistics. Artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning enhance predictive capabilities, allowing organizations to assess potential disaster impacts and optimize supply chain operations. Machine learning algorithms refine response strategies by analyzing historical data, improving efficiency. Blockchain technology is leveraged to enhance transparency and accountability in relief operations, ensuring that funds and resources are securely tracked from donors to beneficiaries. Meanwhile, renewable energy solutions, such as solar panels, are increasingly deployed to power temporary shelters, hospitals, and communication networks, reducing reliance on conventional energy sources in crises. Additionally, collaborations with the private sector are expanding as businesses contribute expertise and resources, including warehousing and transportation, to strengthen disaster logistics and response efforts. Enhancing logistics in disaster relief requires a multifaceted approach that prioritizes preparedness, technological integration, community engagement, and sustainability. Pre-positioning critical supplies and ensuring adequately trained personnel can significantly reduce response times, enabling more efficient aid delivery. Integrating emerging technologies like artificial intelligence and robotics can further streamline operations, optimizing resource allocation and distribution. Engaging local communities in planning and decision-making is essential to aligning logistical efforts with actual needs, fostering a more effective and responsive relief framework. Additionally, adopting sustainable practices—such as utilizing renewable energy sources and biodegradable materials—can minimize the environmental impact of disaster response efforts, ensuring long-term resilience and responsible resource management. Effective logistics is at the heart of successful disaster relief operations. While challenges exist, technological innovations and better coordination among stakeholders pave the way for more efficient responses to disasters. As the frequency of disasters increases, a proactive and well-organized approach to logistics will remain indispensable in saving lives and reducing human suffering. ...Read more
Multimodal transportation has transformed the movement of goods and people in Latin America by integrating various transportation methods into a unified system. This approach enhances efficiency, reduces costs, and promotes sustainability in an increasingly interconnected world. By leveraging the distinct advantages of each transportation mode, businesses can optimize their operations and deliver enhanced services to their customers. One of the standout advantages of multimodal transportation is its potential for cost reduction. By combining transport methods like rail and trucking, businesses can optimize their routes, minimizing delays and avoiding bottlenecks. For instance, using rail for long distances can significantly reduce fuel expenses compared to relying solely on trucks. Additionally, businesses can balance cost and speed by utilizing sea freight for international shipments and air transport for urgent deliveries. This strategic blend of transport options not only enhances efficiency but also improves the bottom line. Enhanced Flexibility and Coverage Multimodal transport also provides businesses with flexibility in route planning and delivery schedules. When unexpected delays occur in one mode of transport, alternatives are readily available to ensure timely delivery. This flexibility is especially beneficial for companies that rely on just-in-time inventory systems or those with urgent delivery requirements. Passengers can also enjoy better coverage through multimodal systems. Combining modes such as trains, buses, and even shared scooters allows users to travel more efficiently than if they were limited to a single transport method. For instance, a passenger might take a train to reach a bus terminal and then hop on a scooter to reach their final destination, creating a seamless travel experience. Promoting Sustainability and Efficiency As environmental concerns become more pressing, multimodal transportation offers significant ecological benefits. Each transport mode has different energy efficiency profiles, and by selecting the most environmentally friendly options, we can significantly reduce carbon emissions. For example, choosing rail transport for long-haul freight instead of road transport can lead to substantial decreases in greenhouse gas emissions. Moreover, multimodal systems encourage the adoption of cleaner energy technologies, such as electric vehicles and hybrid buses, promoting a shift away from fossil fuels. In urban settings, multimodal transportation helps alleviate traffic congestion by incorporating public transit, cycling, and pedestrian pathways. When cities design transportation networks that encourage a blend of these modes, residents are more likely to forgo private vehicle usage, resulting in less traffic and improved quality of life. Multimodal transportation not only optimizes the existing infrastructure and reduces environmental impact but also enhances flexibility and overall efficiency, making it a pivotal strategy for the future of transport and logistics. ...Read more
In Canada's complex transportation network, container drayage is a vital service that ensures the seamless transfer of freight between different points in the supply chain. While often overlooked, reliable drayage is crucial for maintaining efficiency, ensuring goods are moved smoothly, and complying with regional regulations. In regions where logistics infrastructure is evolving, neglecting proper drayage services can disrupt the entire flow of goods. Delays, unexpected costs, and even legal complications can arise when shipments do not transition smoothly between ports, terminals, and distribution hubs. A dependable drayage service is, therefore, indispensable for the efficiency and reliability of any supply chain. What Are the Causes of Operational Delays and Supply Chain Disruptions? Inadequate drayage services can severely impact the operational flow of goods within Canada. The failure to move containers promptly creates bottlenecks that ripple throughout the entire logistics process. When containers are delayed at ports or terminals, this affects subsequent transportation schedules, leading to extended delivery times and missed deadlines. Additionally, poor coordination between terminals and distribution hubs can result in reduced visibility into shipments. This lack of transparency makes it challenging for logistics managers to track shipments, forecast delivery times, and align activities across the supply chain. In addressing Operational Delays and Supply Chain Disruptions, Jack Rutherford Customs Brokers Limited supports compliance-driven cargo movement by managing customs processes critical to cross-border container flows. The cumulative effect of these gaps is increased inefficiency and higher operational costs. In Canada, drayage services are subject to specific regional regulations and safety standards. Unreliable drayage providers may not be fully equipped to navigate the complexities of these requirements, which can lead to potential compliance issues. Delays in meeting local or federal regulations, such as customs procedures or transportation safety checks, can lead to legal disputes, fines, or additional inspections. AMT Marine Software delivers digital platforms improving shipment visibility and coordination across terminals and distribution hubs. Without a reliable drayage provider that understands the regional compliance landscape, companies risk exposure to regulatory challenges that could delay goods and increase costs. A service provider that is well-versed in the regulations not only ensures timely deliveries but also safeguards against legal complications. What Are the Implications of Rising Expenses and Strategic Constraints? When drayage services are unreliable, the costs associated with supply chain operations tend to rise. Missing deadlines, increased handling times, and delays in container movement result in higher operational expenses. For example, containers may need to be held for longer periods, leading to additional storage fees or urgent re-routing costs. When drayage services are not dependable, companies may be forced to rely on more expensive contingency measures, such as air freight or expedited ground services. Over time, these increased costs can erode profit margins and undermine the financial stability of the supply chain. In the long run, the strategic flexibility of a business is also compromised, as unreliable services limit growth opportunities and the ability to adapt to shifting market conditions. ...Read more